From 2012 through 2024, 90 counseling students have been awarded the Pete Warren Fellows Scholarships. The students come from 17 Virginia colleges, and they pursued either a Masters Degree or a PhD in a counseling program.
| VCAF PETE WARREN FELLOWS RECIPIENTS | |||
| YEAR | FIRST NAME | LAST NAME | COLLEGE/UNIV. |
| 2012 | Carrie | Brill Sanders | Virginia Tech |
| 2012 | Emily | Goodman-Scott | Virginia Tech |
| 2012 | Jessica | Lloyd-Hazlett | College of William and Mary |
| 2012 | Mia | Mickenberg | Virginia Tech |
| 2013 | Susan | Branco Alvarado | Virginia Tech |
| 2013 | Lauren | Ellington | Virginia Commonwealth U |
| 2013 | Jennifer | Keith | Virginia Tech |
| 2013 | Thom | Field | James Madison U |
| 2013 | Cassandra Ann | Jones | James Madison U |
| 2013 | Anne | Loyer Metz | James Madison U |
| 2013 | Joanne | Paek | Longwood U |
| 2014 | Emily | Bess | U of Virginia |
| 2014 | Brian | Caperton | James Madison U |
| 2014 | Alyssa | Dahn | Virginia Tech |
| 2014 | Arielle | Estes | Virginia Tech |
| 2014 | Jeremy | Ruckstaetter | Regent U |
| 2014 | Angela | Strite | James Madison U |
| 2015 | Karen | Burke | Virginia Tech |
| 2015 | Jen | Gerlach | Virginia Commonwealth U |
| 2015 | Harrison | Hayes | Virginia Commonwealth U |
| 2015 | Grace | Hipona | Argosy U |
| 2015 | Victoria | Holmes | Marymount U |
| 2015 | Priscilla | Reynolds | Lynchburg U |
| 2015 | Amrita | Sethi | Longwood U |
| 2016 | Monica | Band | Marymount U |
| 2016 | Chris | Barnes | Longwood U |
| 2016 | A’tasha | Christian | South U |
| 2016 | Cameron | Patterson | Longwood U |
| 2016 | Tim | Sosin | Liberty U |
| 2016 | Gary | Wardlaw | Liberty U |
| 2017 | Alexandra | Bazdar | William and Mary |
| 2017 | T’Airra | Belcher | Old Dominion U |
| 2017 | Kathryn | Cohen | U of Richmond |
| 2017 | Ragan | Killen | Old Dominion U |
| 2017 | Sean | Newhart | William and Mary |
| 2017 | Laura | Pignato | William and Mary |
| 2018 | Jessica | Bardenheier | Longwood U |
| 2018 | Katelyn | Childs | Lynchburg U |
| 2018 | Cierra | Davis | James Madison U |
| 2018 | Justin | Jordan | Virginia Tech |
| 2018 | Keaghlan | Macon | Liberty U |
| 2018 | Ariann | Robino | Virginia Tech |
| 2018 | Betsy | Zimmerman | Old Dominion U |
| 2019 | Michael | Deitz | Virginia Commonwealth U |
| 2019 | Melissa | Fisher | Eastern Mennonite U |
| 2019 | Alexandra | Gantt | Regent U |
| 2019 | Tyreeka | Moore | Virginia Commonwealth U |
| 2019 | Aiyanne | Payne | Virginia Commonwealth U |
| 2019 | Garrett | Serrels | Eastern Mennonite U |
| 2019 | Jonathan | Wiley | Virginia Tech |
| 2020 | Paul | Delaughter | Virginia Tech |
| 2020 | Allison | Dukes | College of William and Mary |
| 2020 | Ellie | Hershberger | Eastern Mennonite |
| 2020 | Erin | Mahone | Longwood U |
| 2020 | Nathaniel | Mason | College of William and Mary |
| 2020 | Beth | Orrison | Old Dominion U |
| 2020 | Baylee | Worth | Lynchburg U |
| 2020 | Danielka | Zeledon | George Mason U |
| 2021 | Kaitlin | Hinchey | College William and Mary U |
| 2021 | Kelly | Kaczmarczyk | Regent U |
| 2021 | Jesse | Kelly | Virginia Tech |
| 2021 | Kelly | Eikenberg | Virginia Tech |
| 2021 | Hayley | Rose | Liberty U |
| 2021 | Brianna | Hurley | George Mason U |
| 2021 | Latiesha | Wiggins | Old Dominion U |
| 2022 | Essie | Connor | George Mason U |
| 2022 | Courtney | Dressler | Virginia Commonwealth U |
| 2022 | Melinda | Espinoza | U of Virginia |
| 2022 | Erin | Glisson | Virginia Commonwealth U |
| 2022 | Tra | Nicholson | U of Lynchburg |
| 2022 | Vjay | Paralka | Old Dominion U |
| 2023 | Saudamini | Agarwal | Virginia Tech |
| 2023 | Enoch | Bullock | College of William and Mary |
| 2023 | Samantha | Connor | U of Virginia |
| 2023 | Kendall | Keyser | Virginia Tech |
| 2023 | Madison | Moore | James Madison U |
| 2023 | Jodi | Quinlavin | U of Lynchburg |
| 2023 | Annie | Schmidt | Virginia Tech |
| 2023 | Kristen | Tuxbury | Virginia Commonwealth U |
| 2024 | Zubeyde | Akpakir | Old Dominion U |
| 2024 | Amanda | Furr | Bluefield U |
| 2024 | Victoria | Higginbottom | Longwood U |
| 2024 | Phylicia | Littleton | Regent U |
| 2024 | Kirsten | McPherson | Bluefield U |
| 2024 | Kara | Pfohl | Longwood U |
| 2024 | Morgan | Robertson | U of Lynchburg |
| 2024 | Danielle | Rodgers | Old Dominion U |
| 2024 | Sabrina | Vasquez Ruiz | College of William and Mary |
| 2024 | Yi-Yun (Minnie) | Tsai | College of William and Mary |
| 2024 | Amanda | Williams | George Mason U |