From 2012 through 2025, 100 counseling students have been awarded the Pete Warren Fellows Scholarships. The students come from 17 Virginia colleges, and they pursued either a master’s degree or a Ph.D. in a counseling program.
| Year | Name | School |
| 2025 | Crowe, Jackson | University of Lynchburg |
| Evans, Ajayla | Old Dominion University | |
| Kauffman, Alexis | William & Mary | |
| Keene, Cheri | Bluefield University | |
| Keesee, Anna | Longwood University | |
| Munthali, Glory | William & Mary | |
| Papp, Ariela | William & Mary | |
| Redd, Samantha | Regent University | |
| Turner, Christine | Old Dominion University | |
| 2024 | Akpakir, Zubeyde | Old Dominion University |
| Furr, Amanda | Bluefield University | |
| Higginbottom, Victoria | Longwood University | |
| Littleton, Phylicia | Regent University | |
| McPherson, Kirsten | Bluefield University | |
| Pfohl, Kara | Longwood University | |
| Robertson, Morgan | University of Lynchburg | |
| Rodgers, Danielle | Old Dominion University | |
| Tsai, Yi-Yun (Minnie) | William & Mary | |
| Vasquez Ruiz, Sabrina | William & Mary | |
| Williams, Amanda | George Mason University | |
| 2023 | Agarwal, Saudamini | Virginia Tech |
| Bullock, Enoch | William & Mary | |
| Connor, Samantha | University of Virginia | |
| Keyser, Kendall | Virginia Tech | |
| Moore, Madison | James Madison University | |
| Quinlavin, Jodi | University of Lynchburg | |
| Schmidt, Annie | Virginia Tech | |
| Tuxbury, Kristen | Virginia Commonwealth Univ. | |
| 2022 | Connor, Essie | George Mason University |
| Dressler, Courtney | Virginia Commonwealth Univ. | |
| Espinoza, Melinda | University of Virginia | |
| Glisson, Erin | Virginia Commonwealth Univ. | |
| Nicholson, Tra | University of Lynchburg | |
| Paralka, Vjay | Old Dominion University | |
| 2021 | Eikenberg, Kelly | Virginia Tech |
| Hinchey, Kaitlin | William & Mary | |
| Hurley, Brianna | George Mason University | |
| Kaczmarczyk, Kelly | Regent University | |
| Kelly, Jesse | Virginia Tech | |
| Rose, Hayley | Liberty University | |
| Wiggins, Latiesha | Old Dominion University | |
| 2020 | Delaughter, Paul | Virginia Tech |
| Dukes, Allison | William & Mary | |
| Hershberger, Ellie | Eastern Mennonite Univ. | |
| Mahone, Erin | Longwood University | |
| Mason, Nathaniel | William & Mary | |
| Orrison, Beth | Old Dominion University | |
| Worth, Baylee | Lynchburg University | |
| Zeledon, Danielka | George Mason University | |
| 2019 | Deitz, Michael | Virginia Commonwealth Univ. |
| Fisher, Melissa | Eastern Mennonite Univ. | |
| Gantt, Alexandra | Regent University | |
| Moore, Tyreeka | Virginia Commonwealth Univ. | |
| Payne, Aiyanne | Virginia Commonwealth Univ. | |
| Serrels, Garrett | Eastern Mennonite Univ. | |
| Wiley, Jonathan | Virginia Tech | |
| 2018 | Bardenheier, Jessica | Longwood University |
| Childs, Katelyn | Lynchburg University | |
| Davis, Cierra | James Madison University | |
| Jordan, Justin | Virginia Tech | |
| Macon, Keaghlan | Liberty University | |
| Robino, Ariann | Virginia Tech | |
| Zimmerman, Betsy | Old Dominion University | |
| 2017 | Bazdar, Alexandra | William & Mary |
| Belcher, T’Airra | Old Dominion University | |
| Cohen, Kathryn | University of Richmond | |
| Killen, Ragan | Old Dominion University | |
| Newhart, Sean | William & Mary | |
| Pignato, Laura | William & Mary | |
| 2016 | Band, Monica | Marymount University |
| Barnes, Chris | Longwood University | |
| Christian, A’tasha | South University | |
| Patterson, Cameron | Longwood University | |
| Sosin, Tim | Liberty University | |
| Wardlaw, Gary | Liberty University | |
| 2015 | Burke, Karen | Virginia Tech |
| Gerlach, Jen | Virginia Commonwealth Univ. | |
| Hayes, Harrison | Virginia Commonwealth Univ. | |
| Hipona, Grace | Argosy University | |
| Holmes, Victoria | Marymount University | |
| Reynolds, Priscilla | Lynchburg University | |
| Sethi, Amrita | Longwood University | |
| 2014 | Bess, Emily | University of Virginia |
| Caperton, Brian | James Madison University | |
| Dahn, Alyssa | Virginia Tech | |
| Estes, Arielle | Virginia Tech | |
| Ruckstaetter, Jeremy | Regent University | |
| Strite, Angela | James Madison University | |
| 2013 | Branco Alvarado, Susan | Virginia Tech |
| Ellington, Lauren | Virginia Commonwealth Univ. | |
| Field, Thom | James Madison University | |
| Jones, Cassandra Ann | James Madison University | |
| Keith, Jennifer | Virginia Tech | |
| Loyer Metz, Anne | James Madison University | |
| Paek, Joanne | Longwood University | |
| 2012 | Brill Sanders, Carrie | Virginia Tech |
| Goodman-Scott, Emily | Virginia Tech | |
| Lloyd-Hazlett, Jessica | William & Mary | |
| Mickenberg, Mia | Virginia Tech |